RISMedia
  • News
  • Premier
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Education
  • Newsmakers
  • Power Broker
No Result
View All Result
  • Agents
  • Brokers
  • Teams
  • Marketing
  • Coaching
  • Technology
  • More
    • Headliners New
    • Luxury
    • Best Practices
    • Consumer
    • National
    • Our Editors
Join Premier
Sign In
RISMedia
  • News
  • Premier
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Education
  • Newsmakers
  • Power Broker
No Result
View All Result
RISMedia
No Result
View All Result

Looking Ahead, Experts Parse ‘Overvalued’ and ‘At-Risk’ Markets

Home Agents
By Jesse Williams
May 19, 2022
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Looking Ahead, Experts Parse ‘Overvalued’ and ‘At-Risk’ Markets

In some markets, the numbers are cartoonish. The city of Punta Gorda, Florida—a gulf coast suburb with a population of around 20,000 about an hour’s drive north of Fort Myers—saw home prices rise almost 30% between spring of 2021 and 2022, a third more than the national average. Three states saw average price appreciation top 25% earlier this year (Florida, Arizona and Utah) and three metros in California (San Diego, San Jose and San Francisco) saw home price growth outstrip median wages by more than six figures in raw dollar amounts.

While experts and economists are still convinced that the current market is nothing like that which preceded the Great Recession, a pullback—small or significant—has long seemed inevitable. When that happens, there will almost certainly be some markets hit harder than others based on the degree prices have been inflated over economic fundamentals.

Ken Johnson, a researcher and economist at Florida Atlantic University (FAU), helps lead a project that compares current home prices with a baseline appreciation relying on long-term historical trends, using a methodology intended to offer “practical usefulness” to consumers and real estate professionals.

By this measure, 99 out of 100 markets surveyed were overvalued as of last month, with 13 metros seeing current home prices 50% above where they should be, and one city (Boise, Idaho) at 75% overvalued.

While eventually, all regions should see their prices fall back to this level, whether that happens abruptly or not depends on fundamentals, and the specific conditions of that market.

Eli Beracha, another researcher on the project and a professor at Florida Atlantic University, said in a statement that even at these ridiculous levels, a pull-back won’t mean homes losing a majority of their values, as was the case in 2008.

“At the peak of the last housing cycle, we had an oversupply of housing units around the country,” Beracha said. “So when prices began to fall, there was nothing to catch them, and we witnessed a monumental crash. The current shortage of homes for sale will help put a floor under just how far prices can fall this time around.”

Johnson said one way to predict which markets will struggle to absorb a downturn is looking at where there is minimal or no population growth alongside the housing price increase, singling out Memphis, Tennessee and Detroit, Michigan as examples of this dynamic.

According to Zillow, Memphis home prices were up 22.7% in April. At the same time, the city actually suffered a net loss of households, according to a University of Tennessee analysis.

Austin, Texas, with a staggering price appreciation of 40.8% by Zillow’s estimate, also grew in population by 2.3% between 2020 and 2021, according to census data. That might make the city—and others like it—more able to weather a downturn, with a thriving labor market and tighter inventory to bolster the real estate economy.

Johnson said the tradeoff is unfortunately that housing will remain inaccessible longer in these areas, while regions that snap back to more reasonable prices will become more affordable in the near future.

“Essentially, you have to pick your poison,” Johnson said. “Is it better for you to live in an area with major price declines so housing is more affordable again, or in an area with modest or very small price declines that keep homes out of reach for many middle-class Americans?”

Two other analyses have tried to break down this concept of “overvalued” amid historically uninhibited price growth. California-based ATTOM Data Solutions published a list of “vulnerable” markets at the beginning of the year, and CoreLogic more recently identified downturn risk in about 400 home markets across the country, rating them from “very low” to “elevated.” That analysis also singled out markets as overvalued, with 65% of its selected meeting that criteria.

Just because a market was overvalued did not automatically leave it at risk for a downturn, according to the researchers.

According to CoreLogic, while Austin is overvalued, the risk from a downturn is very low. Conversely, Detroit was rated as “undervalued” based on the increase in local wages, but still at a medium risk for a downtown overall—again based on fundamentals.

Another market that is not significantly overvalued according to FAU (7.69% price above long-term estimate), but is at risk of a downturn is Stamford, Connecticut in the New York suburbs. CoreLogic rated this city as a high risk for a downturn in the company’s analysis, and in its most recent Home Price Index, report warned that the area has more than a 70% probability of price decline in the next 12 months.

Paul Ferreira, a team leader for RE/MAX with almost 2,000 homes sold in the area, told RISMedia earlier this year that he has been advising clients for several months to hold off on buying out of fear of a downturn.

“If they can’t find the property, a lot of these people are starting to sit out the market,” he says, “And I think that’s starting to affect the market—people’s ability to persevere over all these crazy offers.”

Sellers are looking at what their neighbors’ home sold for a few months ago and listing at unreasonably high prices, Ferreira explains—but are no longer getting offers at that level, at least not at certain price points.

“I’m starting to see a chink in the armor,” he warns.

Using local income levels as a barometer can be useful—as both the ATTOM and CoreLogic analyses did—but that metric is also growing more disconnected from the local housing market, according to Jordan Levine, vice president and chief economist for the California Association of REALTORS®.

Speaking to RISMedia specifically about the ATTOM report, Levine warned that some of the issues showing up in these numbers would be less acute if remote workers and their incomes were accounted for, and that there aren’t as many “fundamental issues” as were seen in 2008.

“That tends to exacerbate the kind of risk factors that show up in those numbers,” he added.

Tags: ATTOM Data SolutionsCoreLogicEli BerachaFeatureJordan LevineKen JohnsonPaul FerreiraZillow
ShareTweetShare

Jesse Williams

Jesse Williams is RISMedia’s associate online editor. Email him your real estate news to jwilliams@rismedia.com.

Related Posts

Break a Leg: How Acting Techniques Can Enhance Your Pitch
Agents

Break a Leg: How Acting Techniques Can Enhance Your Pitch

June 26, 2022
Thoughts on Leadership: Beyond the Good or Great
Brokers

Thoughts on Leadership: Beyond the Good or Great

June 26, 2022
One-of-a-Kind Houston Penthouse Sells for $6.9 Million
Best Practices

One-of-a-Kind Houston Penthouse Sells for $6.9 Million

June 25, 2022
Headliners Week of 6/19 – 6/25
Headliners

Headliners Week of 6/19 – 6/25

June 24, 2022
Harvard ‘State of Housing’ Charts Path Forward
Agents

Harvard ‘State of Housing’ Charts Path Forward

June 24, 2022
New Home Sales Unexpectedly Rise Sharply in May
Agents

New Home Sales Unexpectedly Rise Sharply in May

June 24, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tip of the Day

4 Ways to Get Ready for the Summer Market

From leveraging the sunshine in your networking to dropping FaceTime for actual face time with clients, here are a few... Read more.

Business Tip of the Day provided by
REGISTER NOW

Recent Posts

  • Break a Leg: How Acting Techniques Can Enhance Your Pitch
  • Thoughts on Leadership: Beyond the Good or Great
  • One-of-a-Kind Houston Penthouse Sells for $6.9 Million

Categories

  • Spotlights
  • Best Practices
  • Advice
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Social Media

The Most Important Real Estate News & Events

Click below to receive the latest real estate news and events directly to your inbox.

Sign Up
By signing up, you agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

About Blog Our Products Our Team Contact Advertise/Sponsor Media Kit Email Whitelist Terms & Policies

© 2022 RISMedia. All Rights Reserved. Design by Real Estate Webmasters.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Premier
  • News
    • Agents
    • Brokers
    • Teams
    • Consumer
    • Marketing
    • Coaching
    • Technology
    • Headliners New
    • Luxury
    • Best Practices
    • National
    • Our Editors
  • Publications
    • Real Estate Magazine
    • Past Issues
    • Custom Covers
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Podcasts
    • Event Coverage
  • Education
    • Get Licensed
    • REALTOR® Courses
    • Continuing Education
    • Luxury Designation
    • Real Estate Tools
  • Newsmakers
    • 2022 Newsmakers
    • 2021 Newsmakers
    • 2020 Newsmakers
    • 2019 Newsmakers
  • Power Broker
    • 2022 Power Broker
    • 2021 Power Broker
    • 2020 Power Broker
    • 2019 Power Broker
  • Join Premier
  • Sign In

© 2022 RISMedia. All Rights Reserved. Design by Real Estate Webmasters.

RISMEDIA PREMIER CONTENT

INSIGHTS THAT ELEVATE YOUR VALUE

logo-rismedia-white
x